Supreme Court rules human genes can't be patented
In a unanimous 9-0 decision, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that companies cannot hold patents on naturally occurring human genes, though synthetic versions of those genes may be protected by patent.
The case centers around a lawsuit between the American Civil Liberties Union and Myriad Genetics Inc., a genetic testing company based out of Utah. The lawsuit sought to settle the question of whether or not genes could ever be patented for a period of time.
Myriad Genetics argued genes ought to be patentable, claiming that billions of dollars worth of genetic and medical research is at stake. The company is credited with isolating two natural genes in particular - BRCA1 and BRCA2 - which are believed to contributed to breast and ovarian cancer. Myriad claimed it had exclusive rights to test on BRCA1 and BRCA2. Other labs seeking to test on those genes would have to get permission from Myriad first.
The ACLU, however, argued those genes occur naturally, and therefore cannot be patented. The civil liberties group also argued such patents have the potential of creating a chilling effect on research, and would interrupt the free flow of information. Such a situation, they argued, would violate the First Amendment. The group also argued that synthetic genes shouldn't be patentable by law.
"Genes and the information they encode are not patent-eligible under [federal law] simply because they have been isolated from the surrounding genetic material," Justice Clarence Thomas said in the majority opinion.
The ACLU praised the court's decision, saying patients will have better access to genetic test as a result, and that researcher won't have to operate in fear of being sued.
While the decision seems clear-cut in favor of the ACLU, Myriad did walk away with a significant victory: synthetic genes such as cDNA, a synthetic version of DNA, is patentable by law.
"We believe the Court appropriately upheld our claims on cDNA, and underscored the patent eligibility of our method claims, ensuring strong intellectual property protection for our BRACAnalysis test moving forward," Peter D. Meldrum, president and CEO said in a prepared statement. "More than 250,000 patients rely upon our BRACAnalysis test annually, and we remain focused on saving and improving peoples' lives and lowering overall healthcare costs."
The decision, as The Washington Post notes, could have a ripple effect on pharmaceuticals and agriculture as well as medical and genetic research, though its effects will take some time to be felt.
Cancer: Blood Leukemia Genes Identified
Genes that cause acute myeloid leukemia are identified by scientists.
Lack Of Sleep May Alter Your Genes
Researchers discover one week of bad sleep can adversely affect hundreds of genes in your body.
U.S. Scientists Map Genes of Microbes in Healthy People
U.S. scientists have analyzed 5,000 samples taken from swabs and scrapings of 250 volunteers and developed the first genetic reference map of nearly all of the microbes inhabiting healthy humans.
Amazon's New Patent Will Parachute Packages To Your Doorstep
The patent includes a self-adhesive backing, several parachute chords, a parachute, and a breakaway cover. A number of sensors are also discussed, that could track the package’s descent and confirm its arrival at the correct location.
Trump Takes On Snoop Dogg On Twitter
Days after the release of the controversial music video, Donald Trump airs his grievance towards the rapper on Twitter.
MORE IN ITECHPOST
Fitness Expert, Jolene Cherry, Explains How to Build Good Fitness Habits Using Tech
Cherry explores several different technology gizmos and gadgets to keep in mind when the initial burst of fitness motivation runs dry.
How Do Personal Emergency Response Systems Work?
Personal emergency response systems, known as PERS for short, are systems that help people to raise the alarm and get immediate help when a medical or personal emergency occurs. They are ideal for older people and anyone with a mobility issue or an injury or illness that can cause falls.
Eight Must-Have Tools to Keep Your Car Out of Garage
We all dread taking our car to a garage for repairs. We might just want to avoid the inconvenience of being off the road or maybe the costs associated, which can even lead to knock-on effects on things like our holiday plans.
6 Hacks for Students to Choose a Laptop While on a Budget
The modern world tries to drown us in the sea of choices. One can’t simply buy a laptop - there are hundreds of laptops around and sometimes our budget becomes the only real limitation we can rely on. But how to choose other parameters to get the best laptop possible?