Facebook Criticized For Ads That Exclude Users Based On Their ‘Ethnic Affinity’
Facebook has been criticized for its ad capabilities that determine the reach of ad campaigns based on users' "ethnic affinity."
The social network's sophisticated ads algorithm allows it to include or exclude users from seeing certain material, making campaigns more effective by pinpointing which users are more likely to be interested in a particular product or service. However, Facebook's ad-targeting tool currently includes a "demographics" section that allows advertisers to pick which users can see their ads based on their "ethnic affinity." Facebook began offering this criterion two years ago as part of its multicultural advertising feature.
While the social network doesn't ask its users to identify themselves based on "race," it does determine their "ethnic affinity" based on their activities and interests. Engadget notes that at this year's South by Southwest, a Facebook entertainment executive demonstrated how the company's ad-targeting tool was used to show different trailers of the 2015 movie "Straight Outta Compton" to users based on their perceived ethnic group. According to this Facebook boss, those users who Facebook assigned as "non-multicultural" (i.e. not African-American, not Hispanic, etc.) were shown a version of the trailer in which the characters clashed with police officers and carried guns. Users whose "ethnic affinity" was determined to be African-American were shown a completely different version of the trailer, one that highlighted the historical impact of the film's characters.
On Friday, Oct. 28, ProPublica published a report suggesting that Facebook's preferential advertising based on "ethnic affinity" could be violating the Fair Housing Act of 1968. This federal act makes it illegal to publish or print housing advertisements that indicate preference for or discrimination against people based on their color, race, sex, religion, national origin, familial status or handicap. This is similar to the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which legally forbids the "printing or publication of notices or advertisements indicating prohibited preference, limitation, specification or discrimination" when recruiting workers.
According to ProPublica, when it showed Facebook's "ethnic affinity" exclusion options to the civil rights lawyer John Reiman, he said, "This is horrifying."
"This is massively illegal. This is about as blatant a violation of the federal Fair Housing Act as one can find," he added.
Nonetheless, it is unclear if Facebook's ad-targeting tool is bound by the same laws that legally prohibit the publishing of racially discriminating ads in print publications.
Facebook's head of multicultural Christian Martinez responded to the ProPublica report on Friday in a blog post. According to Martinez, the social network does not determine users' "ethnic affinity" based on ethnicity but on "likes and other activity on Facebook [that] suggest they're interested in content relating to particular ethnic communities - African American, Hispanic American and Asian American."
Facebook was also recently inadvertently linked to a controversy regarding rights to privacy. The social media network was unaware that the location-based analytics app called Geofeedia was allowing police authorities to place a group of protesters under surveillance. Through the app, police can monitor Facebook posts of people in a certain area.
Facebook's Lifestage App For Teens Now On Android
LifeStage, a Facebook app for teens created in August is now available on Android.
Facebook News and Updates: New App Lets You Order Food And Buy Tickets
Facebook has launched a new feature that will allow users to set appointments, and purchase food and tickets from different businesses.
Police Scans Facebook, Twitter and Other Social Media Networks Using Surveillance Tool
Geofeedia, a tool that can access data feeds from Facebook, Twitter and other social media networks, is rumored to be used by police authorities to monitor protests.
Mark Zuckerberg's Facebook Admits to Giving User Data to Third-Party Developers AGAIN!
Tired of promises? Well, Facebook once again gives user data to third-party developers despite saying that they will fix this problem!
Here's How Big the Facebook Advertiser Boycott has Become: What Will Mark Zuckerberg do About it?
Will Mark Zuckerberg come up with a genius plan to save face? Or will bigger names start to leave as well?
MORE IN ITECHPOST
Cybersecurity: The Top 3 Biggest Data Threats E-Commerce Businesses Face
When you make the decision to start your own business, you know you have to accept the good with the bad of it all. In that acceptance, there’s the potential to achieve great success and make more money than you ever dreamed but there are also certain threats posed against your business that can throw everything down the drain… But that’s just a risk you’re going to have to be willing to take.
[Watch] NASA Announces Week Update: What Happened to the Artemis Program?
Could we be closer to getting to the moon? NASA provides updates on the progress.
Minecraft Dungeons Jungle Awakens Guide: How You Can Easily Defeat The Jungle Abomination
The Jungle Awakens DLC for Minecraft Dungeons brings the destructive enemy boss, the Jungle Abomination. Here is how you can quickly defeat it.